Sunday, March 15, 2009

I Have Nothing Against Any God. (Hopefully, this goes both ways.)

After reading through my first post on this blog, I realize it might seem that I am coming out as being against gods. Being what I would term a radical agnostic and, at times, a rational mystic, this is not entirely true. (I also don't really want this to be a blog about religion per se, but given my philosophical temperament, I fear it will become an inevitable thread throughout.)

I have a great interest in reports of the paranormal, as well as hocus-pocus and occultism of all kinds. I like the anecdotal and subjective and enjoy submersing myself in them. As some of you may know, I had a number of "unexplained experiences" with voices and moving objects when I was first pregnant with Caleb. I have never even formed a hypothesis about what might have been going on there, and remain intrigued (although also relieved it all ended years ago).

That said, I do not believe in "the supernatural". I do not even believe in the concept. Whatever there is, is natural. Anything that exists is a continuation of this world. It is not that this world and our perceptions of it are illusions, as some would hold, and there is a different, separate, better (or worse) sphere somewhere. This world is all there is. That said, I am a teeny tiny finite being with marginally accurate powers of perception and interpretation and a rudimantary set of sensory apparatus, and I just don't buy that I am even capable of conceptualizing a fraction of what might "really" be going on, or "really" underlying this existence. If we were to "go somewhere" when we die (which I admit seems unlikely), it would be a natural process completely in keeping with laws we are not currently aware of, but entirely internally consistent with the rest of natural existence.

So (to insert a paragraph break somewhere in this stream of consciousness), I see science as our best tool for the duplication and verification of codified knowledge (you know, stuff we write in books as "facts" and off of which we base policy decisions). I see direct (necessarily) subjective experience as a vital source of knowledge, as every bit of objective information is filtered through our worldview and acted upon via that filtering mechanism. I am also open to the fact that not every experience may be externally reproducible or verifiable, but yet may still be true in the most important sense.

Example: We use the scientific method to determine that certain antibiotics are most effective against specific strains of bacteria, and we reproduce this result and verify it. It is, for all intents and purposes, "true", and thus we should make this antibiotic available to anyone who is found to be infected by the organism in question.

Alternate example: My grandmother thinks Jesus comes and sits on her bed every night and talks to her about his plan for her life. This is not reproducible in my presence, and I cannot verify this has ever happened. But as far as my grandma is concerned, this may be even more "true" than our scientific experiements. I don't have a problem with this, except when my grandma (and others who think they receive knowledge via revelation) start claiming that Jesus tells them His plans for other people's lives. But I am not going to argue about this with my grandma, or even form an opinion about what I think may be going on there.

Now, as for people who don't even believe they have knowledge through direct revelation, but believe they can rely on revelations supposedly received and supposedly accurately recorded thousands of years ago and passed down as "true"....see my first post for more detail.

All this is to say that there could be a God, or gods, or any number of things so huge and mind-blowing and out of my realm of perception that I can't ever hope to prove, disprove, or even intelligently imagine interacting consciously with them. I am pretty damn sure that any anthropomorphized "God" who intereferes with human affairs based on motivations similar to our own (teaching lessons, being "jealous", or being "loving") is just crap. But I'll even give you that he/she/it could be out there like a puppeteer, engineering our little lives for his own ends (what? entertainment? unfufilled childhood angst?). That could be true...for you. But I don't see any evidence of it and I don't choose to live that way.

I hold that ultimate knowledge is impossible for non-ultimate, mortal, extremely fallible, foolish, and weak beings like ourselves, and if we tell ourselves we know "how it is", we are inevitably going to be wrong. All we can do is search and blunder. You are free to do so in whatever manner suits you, as far as I'm concerned.....but, you know, please keep your existential crap off my lawn (you- yeah, you! with the Jesus fish on your minivan!)

Off to nap.

No comments: